The
Effectiveness of a 15-minute Writing Sample for
Assessing Writing Ability
ABSTRACT: This paper describes
action research involving the preparation of a test of English writing
ability to be included in a placement examination. The examination, which
included tests of reading, grammar, vocabulary, and error recognition in
addition to writing, needed to be limited to one hour to fit the examination
day schedule. Based on the observation of test takers in previous
years--primarily variation in reading speed--it was concluded that at least
45 minutes would be needed for the non-writing portions of the test. Thus,
15 minutes was allocated for writing. Another factor was that the writing
test had to be short enough to be scored quickly by a limited number of
scorers. With these points in mind, the research questions became the
following: (1) Can a 15-minute test of writing ability tell us enough about
the students’ ability to distinguish between high, medium, and low ability
writers? (2) Can such a short test provide information about writing ability
beyond sentence level grammar and syntax? That is, can it indicate, for
example, coherence, unity, and organizational competence? To answer, these
and related questions, a pilot study was conducted with four groups of
Japanese learners of English in Japan: two groups of second-year university
students (English majors and non-majors), and one group each of first- and
second year junior college students (English majors). It was predicted that
there would be significant differences between first- and second-year
English major students, between junior college and university students, and
between English major and non-English major students. The paper discusses
the complexity of the findings and the factors that contributed to the
decision to modify the time limit for the writing test.
Selected References
(forthcoming)
|